Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Brookfield, MA
Thanked 438 Times in 281 Posts
I used to commute in the rain a lot and if I still did that regularly I'd leave the fender on.
Now I ride strictly for recreation and avoid riding in the rain, so I use a fender eliminator.
I initially bought a cheap Hotbodies one. All plastic, but it held up for a couple of years anyway.
Replaced it with a Yoshimura. Metal, much better quality and the LED lights are a big bonus.
It's been on for 2 years and is head and shoulders above the Hotbodies one.